Dan Bahadur Karki’s removal and Manoj KC’s appointment have reignited questions about political interference, institutional independence and the future of professional policing in Nepal.
Former IGP Dan Bahadur Karki.
KATHMANDU: Kathmandu witnessed another consequential change in Nepal’s security establishment on November 4, 2026. A Cabinet decision removed Dan Bahadur Karki from the position of Inspector General of Nepal Police, appointed him as the prime minister’s special security adviser and elevated Additional Inspector General Manoj Kumar KC to lead the police organisation.
The government described the decision as a redistribution of responsibilities rather than disciplinary action against Karki. But the decision immediately raised questions. If the government had no concerns about his performance, why did it change the country’s top police leadership? And if there were concerns, why were the reasons not publicly explained?
The decision came against the backdrop of several weeks of growing tensions involving the police leadership, the prime minister’s secretariat and politically sensitive investigations. The Inam Sapkota case, disagreements over arrest instructions to former Chief Jusitce Cholendra Rana, leaks of investigation materials including what’s app communications, police action against journalists and controversy over the procurement of election police uniforms had all entered public debate.
Not all these developments have been conclusively linked to Karki’s sudden removal. Nevertheless, together they provide an important context for understanding the growing strain between the government and the police leadership.
The central issue is no longer simply why one police chief lost his position. It is whether Nepal’s police leadership can operate independently when its investigations or decisions become politically inconvenient.
A leadership change before the end of a tenure
Karki was appointed Inspector General by the Cabinet on November 10, 2025, and assumed office on November 13. He became Nepal Police’s 33rd Inspector General.
He joined the police service as an inspector on March 31, 1998. Under the applicable 30-year service framework, he was expected to remain in service until March 2028, subject to the relevant legal provisions.
His appointment had followed a competitive process involving other senior officers, including Rajan Adhikari and Manoj KC, who had joined the police service around the same period.
The government at the time selected Karki on the basis of seniority, professional performance and leadership capability.
Less than a year later, however, the leadership changed.
The Cabinet appointed KC as the new Inspector General on November 4, 2026. Government spokesperson Sasmit Pokharel said the government had created a special security adviser position at the prime minister’s office and assigned Karki to the role.
The government maintained that no disciplinary action had been taken against Karki.
But an administrative explanation does not resolve the institutional questions. The Inspector General commands the entire police organisation, oversees operational priorities and exercises authority over its senior leadership. Transferring that responsibility to another officer is a consequential decision, regardless of the designation given to the outgoing chief.
Was the decision a routine administrative adjustment, a response to a loss of political confidence or an attempt to resolve a confrontation between the government and the police leadership? The government has yet to provide a comprehensive public explanation addressing these questions.
The Inam Sapkota connection

Inam Sapkota
The Inam Sapkota investigation is central to understanding the controversy.
Sapkota, a figure whose alleged political, administrative and judicial connections attracted public attention, became the subject of a police investigation. Allegations surrounding his ability to influence appointments, legal proceedings and government decisions brought several powerful individuals into the public debate.
After police took him into custody on September 27, 2026, information extracted from his mobile phone became an important part of the investigation.
Leaked investigation files discussed communications involving Supreme Court Justice Hariprasad Phuyal, name of Chief Justice Manj Kumar Sharma and individuals connected to the political establishment.
Communications between Sapkota and Justice Phuyal concerning a matter before the Supreme Court.
Phuyal acknowledged having contact with Sapkota but denied any improper financial or ethical conduct. He reportedly said Sapkota had introduced himself as a representative of the prime minister.
Such communications may warrant investigation, but their existence alone does not establish that a judicial decision was influenced or that financial misconduct occurred.
The name of Prime Minister Balen and Kumar Banjankar, known as Kumar Ben, a chief adviser to the prime minister, also appeared in the controversy.
Officials from the prime minister’s secretariat reportedly maintained that Sapkota had misused the prime minister’s name. However, questions emerged about the handling of Sapkota’s mobile phone, access to the device and the procedures followed before its forensic examination.
Ben hold the Sapkota two mobiles for two days raised concerns about the phone’s chain of custody, including that individuals connected to the prime minister’s secretariat had gained access to it.
These are not merely technical questions. Digital evidence is only as reliable as the procedures used to collect, preserve, access and examine it.
If the chain of custody was compromised, the credibility of the investigation could be affected. Establishing exactly who handled the device, when access occurred and whether the original evidence remained intact is therefore essential.
A confrontation with the prime minister’s secretariat
Growing tensions between Karki and Prime Minister Balendra Shah’s secretariat has long been visible problems. Karki had shared sensitive information with the prime minister during the Sapkota investigation. Some officials in the secretariat became dissatisfied with the information being communicated and questioned whether the police chief had disclosed more than necessary.
These accounts have largely relied on unnamed sources. Without direct confirmation from the prime minister, his advisers and the police leadership, they cannot be treated as established explanations for the decision.
A particularly sensitive allegation concerns arrest instructions.
An official from the prime minister’s secretariat claimed that Karki had questioned instructions to arrest certain individuals, including former chief justice Cholendra Shumsher Rana to other individuals without sufficient legal grounds.

Former Chief Justice Cholendra Shumsher Rana. File photo
The underlying disagreement appears to have concerned the limits of executive authority and the operational responsibilities of the police chief. The government can establish security priorities and direct law-enforcement agencies to enforce the law. But an arrest must have a valid legal basis. Political instructions cannot substitute for evidence or statutory requirements.
Police leadership cannot use professional independence as a justification for obstructing legitimate investigations or protecting influential individuals.
The critical question is whether Karki was insisting on lawful procedures or whether he was delaying legitimate law-enforcement action.
That question cannot be answered through political claims alone. It requires access to written instructions, police records, investigation files and responses from the individuals involved.








Comments
0 commentspsst, say something nice 💬